Best Worms for Composting

Best Worms For Composting

Composting with worms is a technique that expedites the process of producing rich compost for your gardening needs. The use of worms eliminates odor while contributing certain elements to the organic matter. This guide provides you with exclusive information on the best worms for composting.

If you’re unsure what the right worms for the task are, you may have to conduct a little research to find out what type of worm would be suitable for the kind of waste you intend to compost. That may be a bit of a drag, which is why we have done all the hard work for you! 

In this guide, we have researched and outlined the best worms for composting that will give you the break you need from stirring. The following are the best worms for composting!

1. Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm European Nightcrawlers Composting and Fishing Worms 2 Lb Pack

Uncle Jim’s European Nightcrawlers Composting Worms make for good composting worms as they make burrows of tunnels in the soil, allowing air and water to flow into the system. 

These worms are excellent tillers; they burrow, aerate and aid in soil nutrient dispersal. The European Night Crawler is the larger cousin of the Red Wiggler Worm and is also known as Euros, or Giant Redworms. They eat up to their own weight a day, producing waste and turning it into rich compost. 

These mid-range dwellers are usually found in the top 18 inches of the soil, bearing a pink-grey appearance with a striped look, thick as a pencil with the tip of the tail being a cream or pale yellow. 

These Super Red Worms are easy to raise. They breed quickly and are fast-growing to 3-8 inches long. These worms are 2 to 3 times bigger than their smaller cousins, the red wigglers (Eisenia Fotida).

In this set, there are approximately 600 worms per pound, great for larger foods and tougher material that has not been pre-composted. Composting with nightcrawlers can be faster than traditional worm composting. 

Nightcrawlers eat more than red wigglers and have specific bedding needs – coconut fiber sheeting. Composting with nightcrawlers can provide gardeners with organic self-fertilizing soil all year long.


  • Manufacturer: Uncle Jim’s Worm Farm
  • ASIN: B001OOD8NW
  • Item model number: 2 lbs
  • Worm Quantity: 600 per pound


  • Compost waste fast
  • Aerate the soil
  • Lively breeders
  • Great for outdoor composting
  • Longer and thicker body 


  • Doesn’t eat as fast as Red Wigglers
  • Sensitivity to extreme weather conditions 
  • Not great at soil aeration 

2. Ficarro Farms 45 – Organic Live Red Wiggler Worms (Composting Worms – Colony Starter) – Eisenia fetida

45 Live Organic Red Wiggler Worms / Composting Worms are raised without any added toxins, with filtered water, and a mix of paper and wood chip bedding with vitamin and calcium supplements added for healthier worms. The size of the worms will be random, but they reproduce in thousands in just a short time. The plus side is that they are toxin-free.

They also come with a random amount of babies and eggs for free. These Red Wiggler Worms can compost up to 100% of their own body weight, and in a matter of months, you won’t have to deal with garbage ever again. They help prevent you from spending money buying worms every month, instead, you can buy once, and start a colony for compost productions. Ficarro farms seek to provide the worm starter-pack you need for vermicomposting.

It comes with bedding that is durable enough to last till you have extra eggs for a future colony. Ficarro farms not only provide 45 good-sized worms but also ensures that these worms come with cocoon/worm eggs. 

This is a great worm farm colony starter, not only will the worms reproduce, but they reproduce quickly and within months you’ll have thousands. These also make great turtle treats as live feeders, or for many other pets to have a little organic variety in their diet. 


  • Product Dimensions: 6 x 4 x 2 inches
  • Item Weight: 4 ounces
  • Manufacturer: Ficarro Farms
  • Worm Quantity: 45


  • Breed quickly 
  • Composts waste fast
  • Cheap 
  • Operates in a wide range of weather conditions 
  • Fast delivery
  • Toxin-free


  • Sensitivity to bright light
  • Prone to tearing because of thin skin
  • Small-sized 

3. Tip Top Bio-Control Nature’s Good Guys 300 Live Red Worms / Red Wigglers 

Nature’s Good Guys 300 Live Red Worms (also called Red Wigglers) are designed to outperform other earthworms because as they travel through soil, they consume and create air passages that help aerate and amend the soil. 

Red Worms will consume any kind of biodegradable matter (fruits, veggies, coffee grounds, eggshell) and while consumption is going on, they produce worm casting which is very rich in nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, and many micronutrients.

Red worms can be used in indoor and outdoor composting and can treat up to 600 Sq. Ft. Nature’s Good Guys Red Worms eat their weight every 24 hours and so you can rest assured that your compost will be large and full of nutrients. Red worms generally prefer temperatures in the 55 to 77-degree range. If you live in an area that has harsh winters, you’ll need to move your bin inside during the winter months or compost on a seasonal basis. 

These worms populate fast, and the recommended bedding perfect for them should be made from shredded newspapers and compost or good garden soil. The more the worms, the quicker they eat through the waste, and the quicker they compost.


  • Item Weight: 1 pound
  • Manufacturer: Tip Top Bio-Control
  • ASIN: B004O3ECJE
  • Item model number: TheFuture
  • Worm Quantity: 300


  • Grows fast
  • Easy to care for 
  • Quickens composting
  • Nutrients from the casting
  • Dual-use for indoor and outdoor bins
  • Voracious eaters 


  • Usually up to 300 worms
  • Not safe for ordering during hot weather

4. Detroit Worm Co 1000 Red Wigglers Composting Worms Live WWJD worms

Detroit Worm Co Composting Worms kicks it up a notch by supplying 1,000 live worms guaranteed to arrive alive and healthy upon delivery. Red Wigglers are best for composting in an indoor worm bin or a sheltered environment (easily made out of plastic tote bins that can be kept in close proximity to living spaces) that are filled with soil. When introduced to the garden soil, WWJD Worms Garden Worms create water channels and air passages thus increasing soil aeration and moisture retention.

These worms are voracious eaters, quickly devouring kitchen waste, leaving behind nutrient-rich castings. The castings and compost “tea” – the excess moisture from the activities of the worms – can be used in your gardens as one of the best sources of organic matter to feed your living soils. 

1,000 Red Wiggler composting worms can create between 8 and 16 ounces of compost per month. If you’re interested in large compost production, then this may be the right option.

These worms tend to double in population every 3 months, so as your worm population grows, the number of castings that they can create will grow, as well, enriching your compost even more. A year from introducing your Detroit Worm Co 1,000 composting worms into your bin, you should have 16,000 composting worms, which will create 8-16 pounds of compost per year! Pretty cool, right?


  • Manufacturer: Detroit Worm Co
  • ASIN: B07888RJQL
  • Worm Quantity: 1000


  • Large quantity of compost 
  • Strives in harsh weather
  • Free guide on vermicomposting
  • Easy to raise
  • Populate quickly
  • Saturate and enrich the soil
  • Live in horizontal & vertical channels
  • Able to burrow up to three feet into the garden soil


  • Mixed with other worms
  • Performs poorly in really hot seasons 

5. – 250+ Red Wiggler Earthworms, Organic and Sustainably Raised – Fast Live Delivery Guaranteed!!! – Vermicomposting Garden Red Wrigglers – Eisenia Fetida – Worm Farm Starter

The red wiggler worms from are live, healthy earthworms that are grown in suitable conditions and are great for composting and producing quality castings for fertilizer. All 250 worms are hand-sorted because Red Wigglers have thin skin and can easily tear under stress. The handpicking process ensures that you receive at least as many worms as you’ve ordered.

Red Wigglers survive in extreme weather conditions regardless of their thin skin. They are tiny and are fast reproducers, laying more eggs that hatch into adult worms in no time. Their growth span is also shorter than other worms. When you receive your batch of worms, be sure that you have already prepared bedding for them in your chosen compost bin.

Red wigglers eat their body weight, thus making composting fast and less stressful for you. The compost is organic and watching the worms eat through the waste in record time is exciting. 


  • Manufacturer:
  • ASIN: B07X49BBFK
  • Worm Quantity: 250


  • Organic and fun
  • Fast delivery
  • Hand-sorted worms
  • Aerates the soil
  • Easy to care for
  • Great for small compost 


  • Smaller-sized worms than other species

Buyers Guide

Regular “hot” composting without worms isn’t for everyone because let’s face it – waste stinks! Composting worms are saddled with the task of breaking down organic matter so quickly that vermicomposting drastically reduces odors. This doesn’t mean odor will be totally eliminated as a well-maintained, healthy vermicomposting bin always has an earthy smell.

Composting with worms is the proverbial win-win situation that affords you a convenient way to dispose of organic waste thereby keeping the environment green, and it also gives worms a happy home and all the free food they could want. 

Here’s how it works: worms are fast eaters, and they will breakdown your waste in a matter of days. Because they ingest organic matter and then give out castings, the odor is at a minimal level. The castings, or worm poop, contain all the nutrition that your garden needs to thrive.

But before you hurry off to start populating your bin with worms, you might want to keep in mind that worms, provided you give them adequate food and a good home, can double their populations every 90 days. It’s probably best to start out with fewer worms than you originally need. 

But how do you find the right worms for the job? Our guide throws more light on the complexities that come with choosing the right worms for composting, also we have provided you with the best options as to what worms are best for speedy composting based on their biological activities and end results.

Is worm composting the best way to generate compost? Let’s take a deep dive into the dynamics of worm composting and what the benefits are in the short and long term.

What Is Vermicomposting?

Vermicomposting or worm composting means transforming your waste into compost, but with worms. Worms are able to break down organic matter in their digestive tracts and in turn, expel castings that are high in nutrients that encourage the growth of plants. 

The plus side to using worms is that the compost created by worms boosts the health of the soil by increasing overall water holding capacity and improving growth conditions for soil organisms. 

Why Worm Composting?

Worms are nature’s ultimate recyclers because the recycling process is done inside their body. As food passes through the worm’s body, the worms have the amazing ability to eliminate pathogens and carcinogens in the soil while adding various beneficial micro-organisms to the outcome – worm cast. Thanks to those organisms present in the worm poop, the nutrients and minerals return to the soil helping to sustain healthy plant growth; it is nature’s way of returning organic matter to the soil.

Benefits of Worm Composting

  • Worms help reduce composting time by 50%. 
  • Worms help reduce composting time by 50%. 
  • Worms help reduce composting time by 50%. 
  • Worms help reduce composting time by 50%. 
  • Worms help reduce composting time by 50%. 

What to Consider When Buying Worms for Composting 

It is a known fact that composting requires the activities of critters as major criteria in order to develop properly. The degenerative actions of worms largely contribute to the build-up of compost. 

A common question would be “what do I consider when purchasing worms for composting?”. The next stage is creating a suitable niche for your worms to live and thrive in. Here are a few things to consider when buying worms for composting. 


When raised in the appropriate conditions, composting worms are often productive. If one chooses to make his or her own bin, they should be sure to drill some holes on the top surface and the sides for free airflow. Worms need moist beddings to thrive, such as leaves, newspaper, and cardboard, this is because worms eat the beddings as well as the food scraps. 

Composting worms typically prefer temperatures around 40 to 80 degrees Fahrenheit at most and need protection from unfavorable or extreme temperatures. This means you may want to place your bin in an area that doesn’t get direct sunlight and doesn’t get too chilly.

Compost Size

Worms have big appetites (especially nightcrawlers) and they are not particularly picky eaters. They eat their body weight in a day, which means compost should be ready after about three months. You will want to consider the worm quantity and the size of the compost you have in mind to produce before selecting the brand to buy.

Composting Material 

The waste you choose to compost should also be considered when picking a worm because worms have different diets, and so they would consume more waste if the material is what they prefer to eat. For example, the Euro seems to love a diet high in fiber and low in protein compared to the Red Wiggler. This is a benefit as high fiber foods are generally easier to find for free or cheap compared to high protein foods. What have you chosen to compost?


Worm composting recycles food scraps and waste, which lessens garbage being sent to landfills, in the most stress-free way! Dump them in, and let them do the work. The worm poop is highly nutritious, giving your soil the boost it needs. 

It is a step towards reducing your eco-print for future generations and a very easy way to reduce, reuse and recycle, alternatively providing organic fertilizer for your garden. 

Wondering what worms can effectively do the job? With the wide range of options out there, our recommendations are certainly some of the best worms that you can get the most out of composting.  

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.